The Real Housewives of New York City has been in limbo for a while now. At one point, fans—including myself—were calling for a reboot. We wanted a fresh cast that better reflected the evolving energy and diversity of New York. The legacy cast had become messy in all the wrong ways, overrun by disjointed storylines, too much alcohol, and a whole lot of chaos.

Bravo heard the calls and did something bold: they recast the show completely. In came Jessel Taank, Erin Lichy, Jenna Lyons, Brynn Whitfield, Sai De Silva and Ubah Hassan—a dynamic and diverse group on paper, with the potential to breathe new life into the franchise.

But here’s the thing: while the reboot felt necessary, it didn’t quite land. The first season struggled to find rhythm and connection, leaving fans less excited about the new women and more nostalgic for the old ones. Then came a second season of the new cast… and things got even messier. Rumors swirled that most of the cast barely speak off-camera, and that their on-screen friendships are more performance than reality. And let’s be real—when the chemistry isn’t authentic, we feel it.

So where does that leave us?

With The Real Housewives of Rhode Island just announced and Salt Lake City proving itself as a breakout hit, it raises the question: Is it time for Bravo to move on from some of its legacy cities? Have we hit a saturation point with cities that no longer feel fresh or compelling?

Some franchises are deep into double-digit seasons—New Jersey, Atlanta, RHOC—and it’s clear Bravo is trying to figure out what still works and what needs reinvention. Meanwhile, The Real Housewives of Dubai seemed to finally hit its stride in season two, offering a glimpse of what a newer, evolving franchise can be when it’s built with intention. Now, only to be paused.

So maybe the issue isn’t just RHONY. Maybe it’s time for new cities, new dynamics, and new stories to get invested in. Or maybe the Housewives model as we know it is slowly reaching its expiration date.

Either way, Bravo has some thinking to do—and so do we. Leave me a comment below on your thoughts of The Real Housewives of New York ⬇️

Images and videos are used for editorial and commentary purposes under fair use guidelines. All rights to promotional materials belong to Bravo Media/NBCUniversal.